Simple & Fun Kindergarten Art Project for When Pencil Met Eraser

This is one of my favorite kindergarten art projects for back-to-school. It is simple and quick to prep, and students love it! Read on to learn all about this easy pencil and eraser art activity inspired by When Pencil Met Eraser by Karen Kilpatrick. Your students will explore subtractive art, practice fine motor skills and pencil grip, and have fun creating art with their school supplies!
Read on for the full lesson plan!
- Kindergarten Pencil & Eraser Art Project at a Glance
- Why this is a Great Back-to-School Art Project
- What Materials Do You Need?
- Prep Steps for this Kindergarten Art Project
- Lesson plan for this Kindergarten Art Activity
- A Fine Motor Activity for Kindergarten
- Want More Than Just a Fun Art Project?
- Want More Fun Project Ideas?
Kindergarten Pencil & Eraser Art Project at a Glance
Grade: Kindergarten–2nd grade
Time: 15–20 minutes
Art technique: Subtractive art
Skills: Fine motor skills, pencil control, creativity
Book: When Pencil Met Eraser by Karen Kilpatrick
Prep: Low
Why this is a Great Back-to-School Art Project
This project is perfect for back-to-school because it gives students a chance to use their bright, shiny new school supplies. It also provides a fun opportunity to practice pencil control and fine motor skills while students are getting accustomed to using classroom materials.
Additionally, When Pencil Met Eraser is a fun story about friendship that is perfect for September. The illustrations also provide a wonderful introduction to the subtractive art technique students will use in this project.
I used this lesson with my kindergarten students, and it is easily adaptable for older elementary students.
What Materials Do You Need?
This project needs just a few simple materials.
- “When Pencil Met Eraser” by Karen Kilpatrick
- Card stock (I cut it in quarter sheets to keep this quick and simple for my students.)
- Tape
- Pencil
- Eraser (a pink eraser is perfect for this kindergarten art project!)
- One cotton ball for each student
- A Work Mat to protect the table.
Students will likely work on this project for 15 – 20 minutes after you finish reading the book.
That’s it!
Prep Steps for this Kindergarten Art Project

This kindergarten art project needs a few minutes of prep to make it successful for all students.
The biggest challenge with this activity is that little hands struggle to hold the paper in place while they color with their pencil and draw with their eraser.
The other challenge (especially in September) is fatigue. Students may not have the hand strength to color a large piece of paper. It is important to fill a lot of the page with pencil marks.
I cut the card stock into quarters to keep this project manageable for my kindergarten students. Then I use painter’s tape to fix the card stock to a laminated work mat (I make these in August, and we use them all year long.)
Lesson plan for this Kindergarten Art Activity
Plan for about 15 – 20 minutes of work time for this lesson in addition to the time you spend reading the book.
When Pencil Met Eraser
Start by reading the book. If you haven’t read it before, it is perfect for back-to-school in kindergarten. It does not have a lot of text, so it fits those short attention spans. The text tells the story of the day Pencil met Eraser. At first, it did not go well. But eventually, Pencil realized that he could be more creative with the help of Eraser, and they became friends!
As you read, be sure to point out the illustrations. They are a great example of subtractive art. Subtractive art is creating by removing. For example, carvers are subtractive artists. In this lesson, students will create art by removing pencil marks with their eraser. It is not important that your kindergarten students understand the term, but pointing out the illustrations will help them easily understand the concept.
Demonstrating the Pencil and Eraser Art
Gather the students so that they can see the projection from your doc camera. I model the correct way to hold a pencil, and I also model the incorrect way. The beauty of this art project is students should use the side of their pencil, not the tip. If they are holding their pencil in their fist, their lines will be too sharp.
I show students how to fill the page with pencil lines. It doesn’t have to be perfect because the next step is to use a cotton ball to smudge the lines, which will fill in any white spaces.
The turning point of the book has an illustration of Eraser “drawing” a smiley face in the pencil lines. I use that illustration to inspire my model. I show the students how to color in the page completely, and then the edge of my eraser to “draw” a silly smiley face in the pencil lines. I encourage the students to also keep their drawings simple – stars, hearts, smiley faces, flowers…. Simple drawings are the most effective.
Tips for a Successful Kindergarten Art Project
If you tape the pages to the work mats in advance, students should be able to easily gather their supplies and get to work. Be sure to prep a few extras, because many students love this project so much, they want to do more than one!
The first part of the project is for them to color all over the card stock. I encourage them to color in an organized way. However, if they scribble, it can still look great. While they work, I move around the class, encouraging them to fill in all of the white space.
Once the white is filled in, students rub a cotton ball all over the page. This smudges the pencil marks, and creates a solid, dark background.
Once the pencil lines are blended with the cotton ball, students use the edge of the eraser to “draw” a simple picture. Smiley faces, rainbows, stars, suns, hearts…. Simple shapes are effective and interesting.
As students finish, I help them peel the painter’s tape off of the work mat, and tuck it around the edges. That’s it!
A Fine Motor Activity for Kindergarten
One of the reasons I love this art activity is that it gives so many opportunities for students to practice correct pencil grip and increase their hand strength and dexterity. Holding the pencil, gripping the eraser, and smudging with the cotton ball all help students practice their pincer grip. A few ways that students will practice fine motor skills with this project include:
- holding the pencil correctly
- controlling the pencil using the side of the pencil
- filling the page
- holding the cotton ball
- manipulating the eraser
- using the edge of the eraser to make controlled marks
As students are having fun, they are also practicing important fine motor skills and building strength and dexterity – and they are so engaged they don’t even notice!
Want More Than Just a Fun Art Project?
This pencil and eraser activity is part of my first Knowledge Builders unit, a content-rich kindergarten curriculum designed to build the background knowledge, vocabulary, oral language, and comprehension skills children need to become strong readers.
Knowledge Builders brings learning together through engaging topics, rich read-alouds, discussion, writing, art, and hands-on activities. Instead of teaching skills in isolation, students build knowledge while using those skills for meaningful purposes.
I’m currently piloting the first Knowledge Builders unit in my own kindergarten classroom, and I’m excited to share more of what we’re learning along the way!
Want More Fun Project Ideas?
Join my newsletter! I send lesson ideas, instructional tips, resources and more – all right in your inbox!
Start with this FREE Make Ten Math Center – perfect for kindergarten!




























































